As the French digital services tax (DST) is in effect from 1/1/2019, with the first payment due in November, there is considerable uncertainty how this tax will be repealed/refunded when/if an OECD DST model takes its place.
The politicians see this as a potential remedy to put out the fire which started with implementation of this tax. However, this issue becomes more complex from an international tax perspective as to how a refund/repeal would be treated: prospectively, retroactively, or some other method.
As this tax, similar to other provisions, was enacted unilaterally by the French administration anxious to improve their fisc, it is now shown to be disingenuous timing at the expense of multinationals which now have to pay this tax. Hopefully, other countries do not follow this lead in advance of the OECD DST proposals.
Not awaiting the OECD’s proposals for which a Workplace will be delivered in 2020, implementation following that several years later, New Zealand seeks to propose a 2-3% Digital Services Tax (DST) in the interim. Public comments will be accepted by July 18th. The Government discussion document and EY’s Global Tax Alert provide details, as referenced herein.
Discussion document highlights:
The Government is committed to ensuring everyone pays their fair share of tax, including digital multinationals. Achieving this will require changes to the current tax rules. There are two options for this:
- The first option is to apply a separate digital services tax (DST) to certain digital transactions. A DST taxes at a low rate (for example, 2% to 3%) the gross turnover of certain highly digitalised businesses that are attributable to the country.
- The other option is to change the current international income tax rules, which have been agreed to by countries (usually referred to as “the international tax framework”).
In summary, New Zealand is not patient to wait for OECD rules, wishes to implement a transition tax in the interim and plans to repeal this tax with the OECD solution when it becomes effective.
The UK Chancellor’s Spring Statement was announced on March 13, 2019 with a focus on the following:
- Making Tax Digital, a light approach to penalties for companies striving to comply
- Digital Services Tax; companies should pay their fair share (also a theme when the Diverted Profits Tax was announced)
- Depreciation allowances
- A policy paper re: HMRC’s approach to tax avoidance, evasion and other…
Additional consultations will follow, including the Digital Services Tax planned for April, 2020.
As the UK is still negotiating its entrance into, or exit from, Brexit, these developments will be especially important.
EY’s Global Tax Alert provides details for reference: